I thought the Lima incident was appaling, but his reaction was more telling of Wigans tactics. He couldn't see what he'd done wrong, which can only suggest to me that they are coached to tackle like that.



If he does come up before the disciplinary no doubt Wigans appeal will be based on 'he's still getting to grips with the superior Super League and its speed, blah, blah, blah.



Struggle to see how the carmont one didn't result in a penalty to Leeds - but refs don't always get it right.

The ref got it in his ear it was accidental and told Sinfield it had been looked at upstairs when he asked about it and that will be the end of that. As for Lima ban him for the season for me.

Yes to tackle round the legs. Very naughty.

So all accidental hands/arms contacting an opponent's head will be waved play on in future?



Yeah, good luck with that one.

Ablett catching S. Tomkins last season they way he did was accidental due to Tompkins' slip



But most Wigan fans wanted him banned for life for that accidental, bungled attempt at a tackle

1 match bans for both. That'll learn em.

Can't you see the difference? Blimey.

& hadn't he done it twice previously without any action from the ref?

Was what Lima did radically different from the tackle by Scott Moore that led to a one match ban?

Have a look at this.

Lima doesn't attack the standing leg, it wasn't even a penalty.

the first tackle on hauraki was high and carmont came in and smacked him even higher. in my opinion it wasn't intentional but it was reckless and he deserves a week off

I didn't think what Lima did was so bad at the time (no worse than lots of other such instances) it was just unfortunate that Clarkson was twisted over by the combination of defenders after Lima had joined in at the side.

yes carmont to be banned, but cross punching sam is just fine