He's not [ithat[/i bad!

Were you at the game NE?

If you had been my recollection is that after the PTB when McGuire was tackled, we whipped the ball to the right, through & past the broken defensive line that McGuire's break had caused allowing Watkins to score easily.

Would the McGuire of old have scored on the break probably; did he panic & throw a speculative pass? No.

Did we score as a result of the break? Yes.

Therefore, in my book, McGuire has no cause to apologise.

Least of all to anybody on here.

McGuire is class and has been ever since he pulled the shirt on. He has to be up there as one of the top 3 Stand Offs this club has ever had.

Better than Sinfield ? ....so why is he playing scrum half ?

I beg to differ about the apology

....grovelling would be in order I think.



To draw the last man and pass to the outside (faster) man is [ualways[/u the better option IMO. Is this is not a fundamental part of the basics ?



Let me be clear....McGuire is a brilliant talent and has scored more than his fair share of match winning tries....BUT even if he had scored here it was still a mistake.

His decision to 'go for glory' increased the chance of a mistake being made (BJB might have knocked on at the next PTB for example). Simples.

Who factors that in to a decision?







If we're going to get that picky, why is BJB more likely to knock on at the PTB than Hardaker is to drop a pass?

Why ? has he chained himself to a chair in Nandos ?

That's Luke Burgess you're thinking of

Nando's had just moved into Australia months before he signed... coincidence?.. I think not

Since when has logic got in the way of a good argument ? You're picking on Hardaker for no reason. Shame on you. ....Bet you were one of those advocating your preference for Ablett at centre ...

What?!?!

nantwichexile, are you Lenny in disguise?