So did I........I guess when we all understand the rules according to Silverwood it will be a far less confusing sport to watch at times

bentham looks like getting the grand final this year imho

You may have a point if either of Buderus' hands were 'trapped'. But, as always, your post is pointless and irrelevant.

Typo and excess words removed for clarity. and also for the benefit of the South Stand at Leeds as well as the Popular Stand at Saints

however as Burrow had not started to regain his feet when initial contact was made the tackle complete as soon as Tompkins touched him - hence when he then dragged him a penalty was the only outcome



contrast that with the decision that went against Wigan where Leeds deliberately wait till the Wigan player starts to get up and then complete the tackle taking him into touch - both decisions were correct and the rules are fine in my opinion.

you also have to consider that Gleeson lead with the ball carrying arm and was trying to free his arm to potentially offload - the ball carrier still has an obligation to retain possession and the defenders have the right to prevent the offload.

That was so funny, I'm still splitting my sides

I agree. But that is different to the scenario that Saddo has dreamt up.

Amen to that. Next season they should start the season by carding anyone other than the captain who talks to the ref. That and charging players for diving.

I'd go for that. Hate him or hate him, Ganson wouldn't put up with responses to refs the last few weeks..... James Graham in particular