Bloody hell, Ryan Hall scored 23 tries last year, 28 in 2009, and 14 so far this season, he made 3300 yards in 2009, 2800 in 2010, and 2000 so far this year, 78 tackle busts in 2010, 70 in 2009, and 44 so far this year, all of these are among the top 20 (most in the top 5) of any player in SL, never mind wingers, its pretty harsh to say he has done nothing.

Quote J20="J20"Yea more errors and missed tackles from Charnely in less games Just kidding they are impressive stats, but has he played centre as well?'" No hes been on the wing each time hes played for Wigan wigan.rlfans.com/fusion_pages/in ... ge_id=1486 He played centre for HKR last year though. Hes prone to the odd error but he does make up for it in the work he gets thru each game. Also the more tackles you make the more you're going to miss I didnt post those stats to say Josh Charnley should be playing for England because I dont think he is ready at all. I just wanted to highlight that fact that Foster is rubbish compared to most, but people rate him because of his excellent goal kicking.

Quote J20="J20"Yea more errors and missed tackles from Charnely in less games Just kidding they are impressive stats, but has he played centre as well?'" No hes been on the wing each time hes played for Wigan wigan.rlfans.com/fusion_pages/in ... ge_id=1486 He played centre for HKR last year though. Hes prone to the odd error but he does make up for it in the work he gets thru each game. Also the more tackles you make the more you're going to miss I didnt post those stats to say Josh Charnley should be playing for England because I dont think he is ready at all. I just wanted to highlight that fact that Foster is rubbish compared to most, but people rate him because of his excellent goal kicking.

ya know who they should groom for wellens FB spot??...tom makinson...

Lomax should have played.



As a winger Foster is worse than average. Charnley is much better and I wouldn't even put him in.

has foster always been a winger?





i ask cos he's not particularly quick from what i've seen....not "winger" quick anyway...but he's got good hands,good feet and can kick a ball......strikes me he's a halfback...or was??? whats he's background??

I think he played centre in Saints academy? Has also played a bit of FB too.

Centre mostly,some at fullback.

Wigoon and Dire fans rubbishing a Saints player,who'd of thought.

Not all of us, he's hardly put a foot wrong whenever I've seen him play. A cracking young player.

wirewonder spouts his jizz on here because he was banned from the widnes boards after we all got fed up with it.

we all know what sinfield can do at 6 and we all know what lockers can do at 6.....on both counts its nothing more than solid at best. if widdop is going to play 6 in the 4 nations, to me it would have made sense to give brown and lomax, who are the two best english 6's at the moment the run. sinfield should be in the squad predominantly as a 9, especially with the roby withdrawal. every time i have seen lomax, i have been impressed



with regards to foster, i would have put him on the advertising posters, but not yet on the wing........

Lomax is better than Myler. Lomax seems to have a more rounded game plus commands 1st receiver better. Myler isnt authorative enough and is not a good enough organiser for England. Foster isnt good enough for England either imo. Not strong or quick enough for the top level, and by the sounds of it his work rate out of acting half aint great either. Some young players hype exceeds how good they actually are these days.

Fro Saints, Foster has been great this season. He's got some good attributes and a lot of confidence in his ability which is helping him play very well. But would I put him in the top 5 wingers in the country (English)? Not really.



Hall and Briscoe have that extra something, particularly size when it comes to playing the Aussies. Charnley is going great guns at Wigan.