"Hey lads I think i have a bite!!!!"



I knew that would work. I thought that a Leeds fan would take me up on my offer rather than a pie. I usually don't troll but it was 2am and I could believe what I was reading. 5 pages on an incorrect video ref desision, WTF, It happens every week!!!! The quality of the refereeing isn't great in this country but the video refereeing (an easier job) is even worse. We have had video referees for almost 14 years now and there is still not an outline as to what they have to check.



Video refereeing in its current format doesn't work. It needs to be re-evaluated or scrapped.

Cummings would very unhappy about having to get rid of the video ref. He would miss his la weekends in France.

you cant even troll good, pathetic attempt. You just sounded like a bitter Saints fan, who doesnt know the rules.

Blind bias at its best





Downward pressure? he didn't even touch the ball until it hit the ground ergo knock on, learn the rules.



As you say, don't let facts spoil your rant

It was a shocking decision and the video refs should have to take some responsibilty when they make calls as bad as this. Bill Harrigan was dropped in the NRL for his shocker the other week. www.youtube.com/watch?v=oezJJ3pu9VQ The RFL need to do more!!

It was a shocking decision and the video refs should have to take some responsibilty when they make calls as bad as this. Bill Harrigan was dropped in the NRL for his shocker the other week. www.youtube.com/watch?v=oezJJ3pu9VQ The RFL need to do more!!

Dreadful decision from a poor referee. Smith seems to specialise in poor decisions, whilst Thaler seems to specialise in wanting to be controversial.

So it hit the ground before he touched it did it?



Errrr no it didn't

Yes it did, the ball hit the ground and a split second later Watts gets a finger nail on the ball, it's a knock on you're just the single most biassed idiot there is, if it isn't telling fans not to bother going to your dump if they want to stand up it's thinking a clear knock on by one of your players is a try. It really is pointless even trying to use logic with you because you don't have the mental capacity (or just plain refuse to want to believe) facts.

You are wrong, he got his hand to it before it hit the floor which is why it wasn't a knock on. Go and watch it again

I just did, the ball bounced as his hand touched the ball, so a knock on.

Quote Gaslight="Gaslight"I just did, the ball bounced as his hand touched the ball, so a knock on.'" blind as well as stupid www.hullkr.tv/?v=40 Watch it, his hand is clearly on the ball before it's anywhere near the ground. The video referee gave the right decision and luckily it's going to be the decision that costs you a play off place

Quote Gaslight="Gaslight"I just did, the ball bounced as his hand touched the ball, so a knock on.'" blind as well as stupid www.hullkr.tv/?v=40 Watch it, his hand is clearly on the ball before it's anywhere near the ground. The video referee gave the right decision and luckily it's going to be the decision that costs you a play off place

Bill Harragan got stood down for his video howler in the St G vs Manly game last week, but I doubt we'd ever see that happen in the UK. I remember when Cummins used to do a column in which he'd argue black was white in the defence of referee mistakes, can't say it inspires confidence.