....and why do you think this would be a good thing for the sport of rugby league?





Not news to us. Why you think so would be though.







Still waiting for your "why" and explanation, if you're able to come up with one.



You haven't offered a single logical response to any couter argument from any poster, and do indeed act like a "Wooden Stand"

Richie, you can keep asking till the cows come home, smokey doesnt answer questions, the simpler you make them, the more complicated he will reply to them, its his brand of talking bollox

I'd debate against you Smokey, but your past behaviour on all forums and even current behaviour on this thread indicates you always entrench yourself in a position and either don't read or only selectively read any points made. As pointed out again, points were made showing the benefits of the cap, but either by selective or unconscious non-comprehension, you miss them. That being the case, if you can't absorb that kind of discussion, what's the use in me trying to engage in one with you?



Wooden Stand is a different matter. He might as well be a posting bot. I don't think he actually reads any posts other than his own - he even quotes his own.

Well, that was the shorter version of what I typed whilst you posted

Thats a cop out and you know it, the total of your argument in favour of the cap consists of I did address this, i didnt ignore it, but if this is your 'benefits of the cap, i just assumed you had something better. It isnt a justification for this cap above all others. If you are arguing for this cap, you need to show why this cap is the best, why that one single positive you believe you have found is done best under this cap. You seem unwilling to do this

Why would I with you though Smokey? As stated earlier, you either by choice or inability don't absorb responses which don't fit your agenda, and take a approach of a debate being something to "win" rather than viewpoint to be sold.

Until you can show you have the ability to absorb and consider information used by others, you will never make any progress.

I notice nobody else has shown any willingness to respond to you.

I could be interested in what you have got to say Smokey, but what's the point if you can't consider responses?

I could give a list of reasons, which you'd copy and paste into a multi-section quote, and then selectively ignore (the Grand Final appearance as your only measure of "success" being just one such recent example) either by choice or inability, what was raised next.

So many people have been through that so many times with you. Why would anyone bother again?

Ok then, don't. You're in favour of the sc but you aren't going to back it up. That's fine

Can anybody else then come out and say why they think the current Salary Cap Regulations are a good thing for the game in this country?



I can't see anything good about them and I personally would therefore scrap them immediately.

Plenty have, you just haven't read it.

When you can show the forum you can discuss, we might. Until then, we won't. Even in that last post, you show you can't.