I take it you don't agree? Hardly a massively dubious thing to say is it?

It is. Jordan Tansey is not in the same class as Mathers.

Tansey > Mathers

Morley > Fielden a.k.a glassjaw

He's not far off. Mathers isn't class, handy at coming into the line at best, a complete turnstile and doormat when it comes to defence.

Wigan pack > Warrington pack.

But Fieldens won more, so he must be better, mustn't he?



Wasn't that the argument you used for Mathers?

I'm not taking that serious, more bait on that hook needed.







So you'd take Fielden over Moz (the guy who also goes hiding from Moz when the two teams meet) ?



If that's the case does that mean Tyrone McCarthy is better than Sam Burgess ?



The arguement i used for Mathers is that he has more class than Tansey.

Point proven about opposition fans being the ones slagging Mathers off.

agree mathers is better than tansey

Somebody who has sense. If Rogues or warrior24 were Castleford fans or any other club they would say the same.