This is probably one for Bilko



Where can I find out the statistics for this guy in regards to handling errors.



He is at times a walking knock on expecially first hit up and even more when we are trying to get back into the game.



Apart from this he is a good prop for us but it seems he knocks on signifcantly more than other props.

Quote King Johns II="King Johns II"This is probably one for Bilko Where can I find out the statistics for this guy in regards to handling errors. He is at times a walking knock on expecially first hit up and even more when we are trying to get back into the game. Apart from this he is a good prop for us but it seems he knocks on signifcantly more than other props.'" Here you go. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 Interestingly he's not the error machine you feel he is.

Quote King Johns II="King Johns II"This is probably one for Bilko Where can I find out the statistics for this guy in regards to handling errors. He is at times a walking knock on expecially first hit up and even more when we are trying to get back into the game. Apart from this he is a good prop for us but it seems he knocks on signifcantly more than other props.'" Here you go. www.superleague.co.uk/statistics ... eason=2010 Interestingly he's not the error machine you feel he is.

Certainly not when you compare him with Gareth Carvell.

[urlhttp://www.superleague.co.uk/statistics_player.php?hs1=2010&hp1=2020&hs2=2010&hp2=220&stat=tries&season=2010[/url

Shhh! Carvell is a prop and doesn't play for us, he's clearly better in every aspect of the game, ours are all garbage

I think we "dodged a bullet" with him.

Rogues - are you saying you would rather have Prescott than Carvell?

On this season form - yes.

No that is with hindsight. Who would you rather have in your squad for next year?

Paul Prescott.

Six years younger, less error prone and a better defender.

Carvell's injury record at HullFC was awful.

When there was all the talk about him going to Saints and it was a done deal HFC fans were suggesting he'd played something like 12-15 games in the previous two years.

He was dreadful v Wigan anyway!



Hopefully Prescott will stay.

As for Carvell, I'm quite happy with the front row for next year with Fielden, Coley, Lima, Prescott, O'Carroll & Davies.

Then there's always the prospect of Hock returning, possibly to prop.

That would give us Fielden, Coley, Lima, Hock, Prescott etc.

In that line up Carvell is too expensive and not required.

I know that Carvell is a big old unit and a Prop foward, but he looks really unfit to me. I am not refering to his injury status. More the fact that he is rather chubby.



I am not fishing, here but with the exception Carvell, Warrington look like a very athletic side.



I know Solomona aint exactly Karen Carpenter, but he does a job. Not sure what is happening with carvell?

I hate myself but that is quite amusing.....