TrinTrin:

I cannot understand the Walmsley issue, after those tries & stopping a try his ability is there for all to see, even Tom now has not the speed he used to have although I do think Tom may have shown him a thing or two as he did with Lewis Murphy ?
Sure he can be exposed as all wingers can & do, his down side is returning the ball but even Tom does not now have a strength in this department. So, if we don't re - sign Walmsley where is there as ready made fast winger - committed to replace him ?
Sure there may be a project player but that has it's learning curve problems ?

poplar cats alive:

Dom Young has been told he can find another club by the Roosters. Now that would be a statement signing.

Butcher:

I think most fans, including us posters, quite like Walmsley. It's not whether he (or Lino or Atoni for that matter) is a good player or not - it's whether we can sign better. Is Walmsley class when put in space? 100%. With a quota spot and money to offer, can we sign a better winger than Walmsley? Definitely. 


Better prop than Atoni? Yep. Better half than Lino? Not sure. If you go through realistic targets...


Cade Cust
Jordan Abdull
Kieran Rush
Rowan Milnes
Tyrone May
Matt Frawley
Lachlan Lam
Drew Hutchison
Sean O'Sullivan
Te Maire Martin
Jackson Hastings
Brad Schneider


...there are only two I'd prefer over Lino - Lam and Hastings. Lam probably won't leave his daddy, and Hastings is a bell by all accounts.