But but Charnley's scored 20 plus tries this season, surely that must mean he's the best in the league!





Like I said on the VT today, no other winger in the league nevermind an English winger. Could of scored that try that he did against Leeds beating about 7 Leeds defenders. He's a great talent!

on his day maybe but not as consistent as Charnley surely ?

Some good and bad, but the good out-weighed it because we found a will and a way to win.

Good to see Westy behind the posts after Crabtree had scored yelling "5 minutes" and within that time we' won.

Whiting outstanding, Heremia brought something we'd been missing.

Well done lads.

Some good and bad, but the good out-weighed it because we found a will and a way to win.

Good to see Westy behind the posts after Crabtree had scored yelling "5 minutes" and within that time we' won.

Whiting outstanding, Heremia brought something we'd been missing.

Well done lads.

thought we deserved to win, was a scrappy game at times, not helped by childs,(who managed to spot forward passes from fc at will yet ignore plenty from the giants!) and a huddersfield team who were intent of slowing the ptb down, constant laying on and not rolling away from the tackle. we seemed to have learned from last week with our discipline!

We looked a completely different team with Heremaia on the pitch.



Although there were plenty of head-in-hands moments watching the team today I thought that a lot of his plays were outstanding.

I would have Briscoe over Charnley everyday of the week. He has talent to create something out of nothing with is pace and power, which I have rarely seen from Charnley.

Reece Lyne would be the top try scorer in the league if he was playing in Charnleys position at Wigan, so imagine what Briscoe would be like playing there. Charnley is a top winger but he's abit behind Briscoe and Hall though.

Wonder if Briscoe will play in the Exiles game, McNamara was at the game today so will have seen Tom have his best game in a while.

Good thatt we found a way to win but thought there were times today we were pretty poor. Very slow, although not helped by childs lack of policing both the offside and PTB effectively.



Impressed with briscoe today who even poppedup on the right wing at one stage.



pitts is way too small to play prop though. Turns his back on the opposition every time he gets tackled, resulting in a very slow PTB

With Charnley rested I would guess so. Good game for McBanana to see him play.

thought watts did well when he came on,will get better to, big unit, think westerman did ok and he cert talks and gees up the players, still think he will be hulls captain one day,all in all a good performance well done lads