I thought overall he had a very good game, although his kicking is pretty poor even by our standards. He also had to spoil himself by putting in a trademark cheap high shot.

He had a very good game.

Decent performance behind a pack that was well on top. Made a few mistakes as well as the good stuff which is being slightly overlooked. If he maintains that level for the rest of the season then an arguement can be made for keeping him as a cover option next year. Not for me though.

Been a big critic of him since he signed, but had a very good game last night, let's hope it continues,



I also hope the club don't panic in giving him a new contract just yet.

Great character, but the worst kicker in super league by some distance!!!

Goldie -MOM for me last night. Great game and great pass to Whiting.

Not seen a pass like that from a Hull player since Cooke left, really missed somebody who can bullet a pass wide, hopefully sorted next year, with the possible new signings

Cooke could only pass to the left though

Was less than overwhelmed when he signed and I'm not going to change my mind completely on the basis of one performance.



However I thought he added something last night we had been missing.



He brought experience and an "old head" to a young team.



I thought he showed great awareness for his try and a surprising turn of pace.



He is also a hard player, something which we have been missing; sometimes we are too nice, maybe we need an enforcer.



Most of all however he played like he cared, like it really mattered to him, not like someone who is here on a short term deal for a couple of months.



If he can control his discipline I think he can do a job for us in the run in.



That doesn't mean I want to see him here next season however.

Wat a master stroke by PG, he had the balls to change our team around and put faith in his tactics and the players abilities. I think McGoldrick has turned into a different player since leaving Cas, he played with passion last night, was one of the top 3 players on the night, hopefully his form will continue to end of season (and maybe beyond) I think PG will keep him around next season if they can get him at the right wage. Well done Goldie (cant believe i'm saying that) keep it up

You can pass me a slice if you want.

In view of earlier posts, I don't think there's enough humble pie to go round. Great performance last night.