Well? I suspect we all know which option will win, but interested in seeing the support beyond both options. This is what you WANT to happen, not what you think will happen.



Stay for me...



(Mods, feel free to merge if you can)

Go....he has 6 wins in 30 under his belt......regardless of the squad HE assembled being injured, he has shown he has no concept of acceptiing it when we get tonked...always trying to take positives from games whan in fact, he should be blunt......we have underperformed since last summer and the buck stops with him.

To replace him? Not sure, but I wouldn't be adverse to a young Aussie coach being given a chance........

Can someone in the “stay” camp put forward a case please?

I don't want him at Bradford

Taxi for BM. Overall we have been in a gradual downward spiral during his time with Quins......he may have plenty of grit and self belief but I think he lacks the flair and tactical ability of his peers. He is no longer enjoying his time at Quins. We have a 20% win rate, we may well finish bottom of the table and he has consistantly proved he does not have any answers. Thanks for your efforts but it is time to go.

McDermott is passionate and knowledgeable about the plight of Rugby League in London. Lets not forget, we have scored some fantastic victories under his coaching - but this season has not been good, owing to inconsistencies in player availablity, which IMO has led to a massive lack of confidence in the team. Certain players have not stepped up, and we are missing players in CRITICAL positions.

I accept that we have had some good wins, but this tends to be the case with most teams in the bottom half of the table most seasons, Salford have done so this year......but a good run of consistant performances remains as elusive as ever. BM may well understand the difficulties of RL in London and to his credit be passionate in wanting to develop the game down south, but then again so did Tony Rae and who is to say that the next coach will be any different. Yes we have been hit by injuries but this is little different to any other side in the bottom half of the table with a thin squad. Regarding players who have not stepped up.......they are his players that he has selected to take this club forward, if he is unable to get the best out of them then that is testament to his poor choice of player or lack of coaching ability. Outside of Walters, I cannot think of another coach over the last couple of seasons who has stated publicly and so frequently that `he has no answers` to the teams lack of performance.

Voting so far......



Stay - 19%

Go - 78%

Undecided - 4%



Ooooh look, 20% success rate for BM.......that sounds familiar

Go - Simple really.

I, like many have voted for Mac to go. But I think he has done a 'decent' job under the circumstances.

But the last couple of years it's been gradually getting worse and worse and some of the performances and results this season have been simply shocking.

Time for a change!!!

Like the team at the moment he is not performing

Time for a change.



I'm writing this having just seen "Boots 'n' All - The Tries" where in an interview they claim Brian Mac would be a great coach at "a club with better quality players". Hmmm